Three Day Road Response Questions

 

1.   In my opinion, Elijah interprits the message as being told to kill all enemies and lose himself. In his dream, Elijah is told, “Don’t fight it,” which essentially refers to the urge to kill people. This makes it seem as though the urge is a seperate entity that is taking over Elijah and his consiousness. When he is told “There is nothing sacred anymore in a place such as this,” this means that there is nothing worth fighting for, but “Do what you can” somewhat indicates that there is. Therefore, I think that “Do what you can” is a cleverly disguised way of saying “Do what you desire” in Elijah’s mind. The word “can” makes it seem to trick Elijah into thinking that his deeds are good. Elijah then actually starts killing anyone who gets in his way with little thought, including allies, because he liked killing. 

     I think that the French trapper and Elijah became similar because Elijah and the trapper both thought that they were doing things for good, when in actuality they were not. I believe that the trapper was less aware that he was bad than Elijah. The trapper believed that he was doing God’s work, while Elijah knew that he liked to kill.

2.   Xavier seems to become jealous of Elijah, because Xavier was the source of Elijah’s skill, but Xavier did not receive any credit for this, or for his own skill. I honestly do not know how Xavier killing Elijah and receiving his identity is ironic, I just know that it is. If I were to state that it is because he becomes the man he kills, I would only be stating the obvious.

3.   I think that the French trapper believed that having sex with Niska would take her spirit was because he thought that Niska was bad and that he was good. Also, he believed that when doing this in a church, he would have the power of God to assist him, and God would take Niska’s power away. I don’t know exactly why the trapper chose sex, but I think it has to do with the fact that he and Niska are different genders. I believe that the trapper would have used prayer against a male shaman.

      I think that the French trapper feared Niska’s power, and that he believed she was a witch. Christians, Catholics, etcetera, believed that someone who practiced things that were “anti-Christian,” or someone with powers, such as a psychic, a magician, or probably even a hypnotist, was a witch who served Satan, the Devil, and that witches were usually women. Niska was considered to be a witch by the trapper was because she was a shaman/psychic. Even though the terms “witch,” “servant of Satan,” or terms similar to them were not used, I think the witch idea is highly likely because of similar events in other media where the word “witch” was used.

4.   Betrayal is not a story about sex; it is rather a story revealing the French trapper’s true intentions, and how he actually felt about Niska. In a way, he did her what seemed like betrayal. I do not believe this is true betrayal, though, because to betray someone, you must actually be on someone’s side first, and I don’t think that the French trapper was ever on Niska’s side.

5.   Grey Eyes: He was basically the equivalent of the “shady man” often seen in media. The man usually makes deals and can often be a loan shark, a member of the mafia, or a man who gets someone addicted to something. The term “hook you up” is often used by this man, especially when he is associated with drugs. Anyway, Grey Eyes is the cause of Elijah’s (and later Xavier’s) morphine addiction, which helps change Elijah in the book.

     Fire: If I am correct, the fire symbolizes Xavier and Elijah’s friendship and teamwork. Whenever a fire occurred, the two would help eachother to escape it and show some of their care toward eachother.

     Flying: I am not so sure of this motif, but I feel that it represents the time when Elijah’s character changes, where he has no emotions and starts killing mindlessly.

     Morphine: I think morphine is what actually affects Elijah’s mind and lessens his care for that which is around him.

6.   “Assimilation” is the word used for when a native child is taken and put into a residential school. Rabbit actually choosing to go represents a successful residential school transformation and the effects it can have on the child’s family members, such as grief. I think Rabbit’s mother interprited Rabbit’s choice as dislike toward her family and culture.

7.   While Xavier did not actually inherit Niska’s psychic gifts, he gained the same morals as she did. Elijah took on the behaviour of the windigo in the book, as the windigo in the book personifies madness, and Elijah became crazed and evil-esque. So, Xavier felt he had to kill Elijah, thanks to his morals, the morals of a windigo killer. In the sense of morals, Xavier has become a windigo killer.

8.   The ending was okay, and I even somewhat think that it was appropriate for this type of novel, or at least I felt, as I was reading, that the ending might be an unresolved one. My questions are, will Xavier spend more time around white people now that the war is over, and would they react the same way as the French trapper if Xavier became a true windigo killer? I feel that the author may have ended the book this way to make the readers think about what could happen after the book’s events, or that because what would happen after the book wouldn’t be as exiting or meaningful as the book itself.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

A Matter Of Balance Essay Rewrite

Logan R A Matter Of Balance Essay Rewrite

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

The Eyes Of Children Reply

In this video, the viewer was shown what Christmas was like at a particular residential school (probably similar to how most residential schools celebrate it). The Native Americans learned about it and the staff put on a school play.

What I saw in the video was unexpected by me. The staff wasn’t acting mean toward the students as residential school staff are known to do. Of course, they probably are mean to the students, but it was never shown in the video.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Three Day Road Reader Responses Chapters 5-13

Logan R Three Day Road Chapter Responses

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Three Day Road Chapter 1-4 Reader Response

LoganR                Three Day Road Chapter 1-4 Reader Response

 

Chapter 1: Ekiiwaniwahk

            I thought that this chapter was a bit boring, because nothing very interesting happens here, and I don’t know anything about the characters. Even though this book was made in 2005, Joseph Boyden does a good job at making the book take place around the ending of World War One. I think this is because Niska talks about the way that all of the Caucasians/white people/wemistikoshiw were looking at her, which suggested racism. In our time, there are few racists, and those who are racists I find are usually just joking people. One part of this chapter I liked was the end, because Niska has “the realization that [Xavier] has come home only to die” (pg. 9)

 

Chapter 2: Takoshininaaniwan

            This chapter was a bit more interesting. I enjoyed it because it gave us information about Xavier fighting in the war. I like action. I also liked the part of the chapter where the man called Sean Patrick is talking to Grey Eyes and Xavier narrates, “Sean Patrick, who’s not seventeen winters but fifteen. And that one, Grey Eyes. Him, he’s a liar.” (pg. 14) It both scares and thrills me a little bit that a fifteen-year-old is fighting in the war. That is one year younger than me (of course, he’d technically be almost 100 years older than me)! And the fact that Grey Eyes is a liar scares me because I feel like he might betray his team later on in the book.

 

Chapter 3: Monahikewina

            I like this chapter for the same reason that I liked the second one. I enjoyed the close call of Xavier being shot at near the end of the chapter, and it “is suddenly very real. The other side wants to kill me, and I’ve never even seen their faces.” I think this somewhat shows the agony of war in that it feels like people you don’t know are trying to kill you for no reason.

 

Chapter 4: Noohtaawiy

            This chapter was kind of interesting because it gives us a background about Niska’s days as a child. I had trouble following it when I first read it, but reading some of it again, doing a questionnaire and having Mrs. O’Malley shed some light on the subject helped quite a bit. There is something about learning certain things about Native Americans that I like. I don’t know what it is. I think that my favourite parts of the chapter were when Micah’s wife and the baby were killed by Niska’s father, and when Niska receives her father’s abilities and says that there is still one more who will receive the abilities, foreshadowing later events in the book. This is interesting, because she says, “I am the second to last in a long line of windigo killers. There is still one more.” This means that once Niska’s successor, most likely Xavier, dies, then the line will be gone. Forever. I have a feeling that the book will get to that point. Therefore, I think that both Niska and Xavier will die in the events of the book.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

A Matter of Balance Essay

Logan RA Matter of Balance Essay

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Community Assignment

I was born in Surrey Memorial Hospital, British Columbia, Canada. I grew up in BC, too.My mom was born in Chilliwack and I believe she grew up there. My dad was born in Burnaby. He probably grew up there.???I have only been to the United States. I never even left this continent.I have been to places such as Vancouver Island and the Queen Charlotte Islands.I have been to Cold Lake in Alberta, and I think Manitoba when I was a baby.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

There Will Come Soft Rains response

There Will Come Soft Rains response

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

“War Pigs” PEE Analysis

Logan R’s War Pigs Analysis

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

English 11 Poetic Terms

Poetic Terms

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment